The Bert and Ernie Principle of Sharing:29-11-2016
When and Why Do Children Give Others the Bigger Piece of the Pie?
In one episode of Sesame Street, Ernie takes a bigger piece of pie for himself and gives a smaller piece to Bert. Bert responds, “That is not very polite. I mean, if I had two pieces of pie, I’d offer you the big piece and take the small one for myself.” Confused, Ernie replies, “Well… you have the small piece, Bert.”
Fairness is a central concept in the adult world. But how do children learn what is fair and what is not? When do children learn to distribute resources in an equitable manner, and what do they do when it is impossible to divide the pie equally?
In a new research, Dr. Shoham Choshen-Hillel of the Jerusalem School of Business Administration at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem, and Dr. Alex Shaw and Prof. Eugene Caruso from the University of Chicago, examined the decisions that children make at different ages when confronted with inequity.
The study shows that as children mature, they develop an increasingly complex understanding of fairness. As they grow older, children behave less like Ernie and more like Bert —although they are not always happy when others get more, they would much rather give the bigger piece of pie to others than waste it, as long as the decision about who gets the smaller piece of pie comes from them rather than someone else.
The research, published in the journal Psychological Science (LINK), found that children learn to distinguish between inequity and unfairness at a young age (around 6 to 7), and that as they grow older they become more concerned with the fairness of the allocation rather than the outcomes per se. This makes them more likely to offer others the bigger piece of the pie.
"Children develop an understanding that inequity is not problematic in and of itself. Instead, they realize that inequity is problematic when it is driven by unfairness or partiality," explained Dr. Choshen-Hillel. "Our past research shows that this is how adults react to inequity, but now we have evidence that even children as young as 7 years of age are concerned with inequity, only when it is seen as unfair."
To examine the way children of different ages divide resources that cannot be shared equally, the researchers conducted experiments with about 500 children who visited the Museum of Science and Industry in Chicago. Each child was told that the research team would like to give them and another child named Mark colorful erasers, because they did such a great job learning at the museum that day. “Mark and you each get one eraser. Now we have one left over. What do you want to do with it?”
In one experiment, children could choose whether to take the third eraser for themselves or throw it in the trash. The results showed that while younger children (aged 4-6) tended to take the eraser for themselves, the older children (aged 7-8) preferred to throw the eraser in the trash. In another experiment, the children could give the eraser to the other child or throw it away. The younger children were more likely to throw the eraser away and the older children were more likely to give it to the other child.
"In both experiments, the choices of the older children demonstrated that they prefer to create inequity but to avoid being unfair towards the other. They disadvantaged themselves and were not concerned about the resulting inequity, because they were the ones responsible for it," Dr. Choshen-Hillel said.
"Previous theories in psychology have argued that as children grow older, they become more concerned about inequity. Our studies show that children develop partiality aversion rather than inequity aversion. They are actually happy to give the bigger piece of the pie to someone else, even if it creates inequity and puts them in an inferior position."
Similar experiments are now being conducted in Israel and in China. The researchers report that initial data suggest this tendency is characteristic of children all over the world.
"Interestingly," said Dr. Choshen-Hillel, "Preliminary findings indicate that children from Israel and from China behave in a very similar way to what we have seen in American children."
The findings shed light on when and how children learn what is fair and what is equitable, an understanding that is central to the grown ups’ world. "We distinguish between different types of inequity, and the key factor is whether or not inequity is seen as unfair or partial," explained Dr. Choshen-Hillel.
The findings from these studies may lead to the development of educational tools to reduce children’s envy and rivalry, and promote sharing behavior and cooperation.
"For example," suggested Dr. Choshen-Hillel, "We recommend that parents and educators encourage children, especially those who are seven years old or older, to make resource allocation decisions by themselves, rather than have the adults make these decisions. For instance, rather than having the parent decide on who should get the bigger cookie, the children should be asked to make this decision by themselves. This way, the child will benefit from giving to his siblings or friends and would be more satisfied with the final allocation, even if he or she gets less than the others. It is a win-win."
Some twenty rectors from leading Latin American universities visited Israel this week and signed agreements with the Hebrew University of Jerusalem, in a first-of-its-kind conference signalling growing academic cooperation15-12-2016
Study of Israeli adolescents also looks at impact of socioeconomic position on subsequent cognitive impairment08-12-2016
Hebrew University Researchers Develop a New Strain of Passion Fruit that significantly protects brain cells and its function from aging-related damage08-12-2016
A history book about Jewish-Arab relations titled Juifs et musulmans en Palestine et en Israel des origines ÃƒÆ’Ã‚Â nos jours recently won the first prize for the best history book published in France in 08-12-2016
Keynote lecture - Child Soldiers06-12-2016
Hebrew University Researchers Bring Home 3 of the 8 EMET Prizes Awarded for 201604-12-2016
When and Why Do Children Give Others the Bigger Piece of the Pie?29-11-2016
Scientists from the Crick Institute, London and the Hebrew University, Jerusalem, discover a protein that plays a key role in turning cancer tumour cells into cancer stem cells that are able to renew outbreaks of the disease22-11-2016
An analysis of graduates employability published by Times Higher Education (THE) has ranked graduates of the Hebrew University of Jerusalem as the 67th most employable in the world.20-11-2016
Governor General discusses collaborative medical research partnerships between Canada and Israel at IMRIC, the Institute for Medical Research Israel-Canada03-11-2016
On the first day of his state visit to Israel, the President of the Italian Republic, Sergio Mattarella, gave a keynote address to an overflow audience, at the Truman Institute on the university's Mount Scopus campus.30-10-2016
Sunday 20th November: 10:30 - 17:00 Paris27-10-2016
Four joint seminars took place, where scientists from the Hebrew University and the University of Vienna met to exchange ideas and to prepare proposals for third party funding27-10-2016
Deborah Steinmetz, Director, Steven Spielberg Jewish Film Archive18-10-2016
International partnership unravels the mechanism by which Hepatitis C Virus (HCV) reprograms human metabolism, and identifies new pathways of anti-viral resistance10-10-2016
Scientists show for the first time how bacterial superantigen toxins work, and how short peptides can block them and save lives06-10-2016
A delegation of Asian religious leaders visited the Hebrew University of Jerusalem13-09-2016
Innovative boutique programme for professional training in the growth, production and analysis of wine, as well as wineries management17-08-2016
Succeeding Jacqueline Caspi as Chair of the BFHU Young Professional Committee is Benjamin Stowe16-08-2016
New finds contribute significantly to research of Roman art in Israel: Provide first evidence of figurative images in wall paintings at the site, and precede earliest mosaics discovered at the site by a hundred years10-08-2016
In a historic find, a large fragment of an Egyptian statue measuring 45 X 40 centimetres, made of lime-stone, was discovered In the course of the current season of excavations at Tel-Hazor, north of the Sea of Galilee in Israel25-07-2016
Dr. Yosef Buganim is a young researcher at the Institute for Medical Research Israel-Canada (IMRIC), part of the Hebrew University's Faculty of Medicine18-07-2016
New molecules, developed by Hebrew University of Jerusalem scientists, reduce inflammation, cell death and cognitive impairments following traumatic brain injury in mice11-07-2016
The Centre for World University Rankings (CWUR), based in Saudi Arabia, has ranked the Hebrew University of Jerusalem at #26 among the 25,000+ degree-granting institutions in the world.11-07-2016
Goes to Hebrew University's ELSC Brain Sciences Centre07-07-2016
Named a Commander of the Legion of Honour29-06-2016
Dame Helen Mirren, one of the world's best-known and most respected actresses, met with Arab and Jewish theatre students at The Billy Crystal Program for Peace Through the Performing Arts26-06-2016
Times Higher Education Asia University Rankings Editor of Times Higher Education Rankings: "It has never been as clear to me that the balance of power is shifting from the West to the East."20-06-2016
Historical survey of excavated mosaic art of pagans, Jews, Samaritans, Christians and Muslims earns Hebrew University professor the first prize in this year's Polonsky Awards08-06-2016
Pinchas Tsukerman developed a novel immunotherapy method in which monoclonal antibodies neutralize the tumor's ability to suppress the immune system07-06-2016
'Striving to expand the government is correct and justified.' President Rivlin, a Hebrew University alumnus, praises academia's role as unifier of Israeli society29-05-2016
The British Friends of The Hebrew University Young Professional Group has held its first dinner. The dinner was hosted by Lord Pannick QC in the Peers' Dining Room, House of Lords26-05-2016
Israeli President Reuven Rivlin, American Jewish Philanthropist Mortimer B. Zuckerman, and i24 founder Patrick Drahi To Be Honored at Hebrew University Convocation22-05-2016
The University of Toronto and The Hebrew University of Jerusalem are pleased to deepen their partnership in the fields of social work and bio-innovation19-05-2016
Hebrew University signs agreements with leading academic institutions from the Republic of Singapore, and confers honorary doctorate upon Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong18-04-2016
Hebrew University's liver-on-chip platform is uniquely able to monitor metabolic changes indicating mitochondrial damage occurring at drug concentrations previously regarded as safe04-04-2016
Yaacov Michlin, CEO, Yissum: During 2015, Yissum founded a record number of eight companies based on inventions of researchers from the Hebrew University Centre for Nanoscience and Nanotechnology31-03-2016
His Excellency the President of the Hellenic Republic, Mr. Prokopios Pavlopoulos, was awarded an honorary doctorate by the Hebrew University of Jerusalem.30-03-2016
Yissum takes part in project to Operate a Tech Incubator under Israel's National Incubator Programme
Jerusalem Venture Partners (JVP) LED Group joins forces with Motorola Solutions (NYSE: MSI), Reliance Industries (NSE: Reliance) and Yissum, the Research Development Company of the Hebrew University of Jerusalem22-03-2016
The haploid stem cells may yield new genetic screening tools and therapies16-03-2016
New blood test uses methylation patterns of circulating DNA from dying cells to detect diabetes, multiple sclerosis, pancreatic cancer, pancreatitis and brain damage, opening up vast possibilities for diagnostic medicine.14-03-2016
The Technology Transfer Company of the Hebrew University, comes to London10-03-2016
Dedication Ceremony and Memorial Lecture on March 14 on Mount Scopus10-03-2016
Hebrew University students develop life-saving device following a wave of stabbing attacks that leaves some civilians with collapsed lungs09-03-2016
Researchers find that a cell aging program causes human and mouse pancreatic beta cells to work harder and secrete more insulin07-03-2016
Hebrew University researchers develop a solution for long-term preservation of cells and organs for transplant, as part of a global alliance to bank organs02-03-2016
Hebrew University formula that activates the body's natural defense against free radicals could control a variety of skin pathologies and disorders29-02-2016
New fibre optic guide-wire will enable surgeons to perform highly accurate hip fracture and spinal fusion surgery with minimal side effects23-02-2016
Scientists At NSF Press Conference in D.C. Confirm Einstein's Century-Old Prediction11-02-2016
Three-Week Summer Program for International Students and Attorneys Opens June 27, 201608-02-2016
Israeli Minister of Education Naftali Bennett has announced that Prof. Edit Doron will be awarded the Israel Prize for her work in the study of Linguistics.03-02-2016
Over 23,000,000 Euros to Promote Groundbreaking Research in Medicine, Mathematics & Sciences, and the Humanities07-01-2016
Supporting the Hebrew University since 192605-01-2016